بوب أفاكيان يردّ على - حسنا ، ما الذى يُفترض أن تقوم به إسرائيل ، و ما هي الطريقة الشرعيّة للنضال ضد دولة إسرائيل ، و ما هو الحلّ العادل ؟ -


شادي الشماوي
2024 / 1 / 30 - 22:56     

بوب أفاكيان يردّ على " حسنا ، ما الذى يُفترض أن تقوم به إسرائيل ، و ما هي الطريقة الشرعيّة للنضال ضد دولة إسرائيل ، و ما هو الحلّ العادل ؟ "
جريدة " الثورة " عدد 838 ، 29 جانفي 2024
https://revcom.us/en/bob_avakian/bob-avakian-answers-well-what-israel-supposed-do-what-legitimate-way-fight-against
@BobAvakianOfficial من
Substack, Instagram, Facebook, X, Telegram, Threads, TikTok, WhatsApp and YouTube

هنا بوب أفاكيان ( BA)، قائد ثوريّ – تقدّم بطريقة جديدة كلّيا ، و إطار جديد كلّيا لتحرير الإنسانيّة : الشيوعيّة الجديدة.
أتوّجه إليكم مباشرة عارضاعليكم الحقيق التي لا تريد السلطات القائمة أن تُقدم لكم – الحقيقة التي تحتاجون إلى معرفتها ... " حسنا ، ما الذى يُفترض أن تفعله إسرائيل ، أن تترك ببساطة هجوم حماس هذا دون ردّ ما يشجّعها على المزيد من الهجمات ؟ و ماذا عن حقّ إسرائيل في الدفاع عن نفسها ؟ " هذه حجّة من الحجج التي ترفعها إسرائيل و يرفعها مساندو إسرائيل في وجه من يعارضهما .
و الحقيقة هي أنّ إسرائيل شأنها في ذلك شأن الأبارتايد / نظام الفصل العنصريّ في جنوب أفريقيا قبلها ، دولة لاشرعيّة – و من ثمّة لا تملك حقّا شرعيّا في " الدفاع عن نفسها " – و ما تسمّيه " دفاعا " قد إنطوى بصورة متكرّرة على القتل المتعمّد للمدنيّين و منهم أعداد كبيرة من الأطفال .
ما الذى يُفترض بإسرائيل أن تفعله ؟ " يفترض " من إسرائيل أن توقف إضطهادها الوحشيّللشعب الفلسطينيّ ؟ إلاّ أنّ إسرائيل كدولة عنصريّة ، دولة تفوّق يهودي ( صهيونيّة ) ليس بوسعها القيام بذلك : وهي لا تستطيع فعل ذلك لأنّ الإضطهاد الإجرمي للشعب الفلسطيني مبنيّ في أسس دولة إسرائيل منذ البداية ، و لا يمكن لإسرائيل أن توجد دون الإضطهاد الوحشيّ للشعب الفلسطينيّ .
و بما أنّ إسرائيل لا تستطيع أن تكفّ عن الإضطهاد الوحشيّ للشعب الفلسطيني ، يجب على إسرائيل – كدولة عنصريّة ، صهيونيّة – أن تكفّ عن الوجود .
و المسألة الحقيقيّة هي : ما هي الطريقة الشرعيّة للقتال ضد دولة إسرائيل ، و ما هو الحلّ العادل لكلّ هذا ؟
و الإجابة ليست نهائيّا " قتل كافة اليهود في إسرائيل " أو " رميهم في البحر " . الإجابة هي أفطاحة بدولة إسرائيل و على أنقاضها إنشاء دولة ثوريّة لا تشجّع حكومتها و لا قوانينها أيّ دين و لا تميّز أناسا عن أناس آخرين ، و إنّما توجد مساواة بين اليهود و الفلسطينيّين .
و نهائيّا ، الإجابة ليست كذلك " حلّ الدولتين " الذى تروّج له إدارة بايدن . فمثل " حلّ الدولتين " هذا يساوى حقّا لا شيء أكثر من دولة قويّة هي إسرائيل تواصل إحتلال الأرض المغتصبة من الشعب الفلسطيني فيما ما يسمّى ب" الدولة الفلسطينيّة" التي يرسيها هذا " الحلّ ط ستكون نُكتة مريرة – دولة دُمية – مجرّد رُقعة متكوّنة من مناطق صغيرة منفصلة عن بعضها البعض و محاصرة و تُهيمن عليها إسرائيل ، و سيظلأّ الشعب الفلسطينيّ عُرضة للإضطهاد و الحرمان الفظيعين .
الإجابة هي أنّ النضال ضد دولة إسرائيل ينبغي أن يُخاض على أساس ثوريّ بهدف وضع نهاية لكلّ العلاقات الإضطهاديّة و كلّ اللامساواة المبنيّة على العرق و القومية و الجنس و الجندر ، و كلّ العلاقات التي يستغلّ بوساطتها قسما من المجتمع قسما آخر . و الحاجة الملحّة هي نشوء قوّة ثوريّة تقود النضال على هذا الأساس .
Follow Bob Avakian (BA) on social media!
Substack, Instagram, Facebook, X, Telegram, Threads, TikTok, WhatsApp and YouTube
إطلالة على مقالات و أشرطة فيديو العدد 838 من جريدة " الثورة " لسان حال الحزب الشيوعي الثوري ، الولايات المتّحدة الأمريكيّة
www.revcom.us
In This Issue… January 29, 2024
January 29, 2024
Table of Contents
NEW this week:
Bob Avakian on Social Media
• “...those of you who are not afraid of the truth...”
• Bob Avakian on Social Media: Have You REALLY Thought About What Difference This Could Make?
• Promote @BobAvakianOfficial! — Share these Designs!
• Follow the revolutionary leader Bob Avakian on social media on Substack, Instagram, Facebook, X, Telegram, Threads, TikTok, WhatsApp and YouTube
Palestine
• From @BobAvakianOfficial: Bob Avakian Answers “Well, What Is Israel Supposed to Do, What Is the Legitimate Way to Fight Against the State of Israel and What Is a Just Solution?”
• International Court of Justice Says Israeli Genocide Against Palestine Is "Plausible"... but-limit-s Itself to an Empty Warning
• Three Ways Israel’s Genocidal War Is Escalating
• [video] REVCOMS: This ICJ ruling is NOT a victory...
• Cheers to the Jewish Voice for Peace Rabbinical Council for their Open Letter, “Sorrow and fury: a letter from American rabbis to President Biden"
• [video] Revcoms in LA marked Holocaust Remembrance Day with the message: Never again must mean never again for ANYONE...
We Don t Have an Immigration Problem—We Have an Imperialism Problem
• Standoff In Eagle Pass, TX: Echoes of One Civil War… And the Looming Specter of Another
• [video] Revcoms at the Eagle Pass Border (stay tuned for on-the-scene reports)
• The Rio Grande Coming to a Boil [updated Jan. 24]
• STOP The Demonization, Criminalization, and Deportation of Immigrants and the Militarization of the Border! A Special Resource Page (updated)
Featured
• In Defense of Bob Avakian and the Revcoms, Part 1 of 3, by Paul Street
• The Body Cam Scam
• [video] Sunsara Taylor & Luna Answer Questions From Students
• [video] Luna Hernandez: What makes @therevcoms different from all the other socialist groups on campus?
• Upcoming trial alert from Lula Hernandez, a revcom in LA: DEMAND ALL CHARGES BE DROPPED FOR STANDING UP FOR ABORTION RIGHTS IN 2022
• Why I put my body on the line for abortion rights... Why I m a revolutionary and follower of Bob Avakian... and why you should be too, from Luna Hernandez
For Black History Month
• [video] BOB AVAKIAN FOR THE LIBERATION OF BLACK PEOPLE AND THE EMANCIPATION OF ALL HUMANITY [repost]
• Montgomery, Alabama—A Visit to the Legacy Sites: Lessons from the Past, Fighting NOW for the Future
• RACIAL OPPRESSION CAN BE ENDED—BUT NOT UNDER THIS SYSTEM, by Bob Avakian [repost]
• Bob Avakian on the Oppression of Black People and the Revolutionary Struggle to End All Oppression—Resource Page
Fund-raising
• Support the team of Revcoms on the ground at the Texas/Mexico border!
Latest episode of The RNL—Revolution, Nothing Less!—Show on YouTube:
[Video] 4 Reasons We Need a Revolution, the Leader Who Can Lead It & the Millions Needed to Join Now
Repression, Resistance and the Potential for Revolution in Iran
• From the International Emergency Campaign to Free Iran’s Political Prisoners Now (IEC): Women Political Prisoners Spur New Burst of Resistance to Executions in Iran
• From Atash/Fire, journal of the Communist Party of Iran Marxist-Leninist-Maoist: Execution Is a Crime Against Humanity!

Also available at revcom.us Home page
From the Revcoms (Revolutionary Communists):
REVOLUTION
BUILDING UP THE BASIS TO GO FOR THE WHOLE THING, WITH A REAL CHANCE TO WIN: STRATEGIC ORIENTATION AND PRACTICAL APPROACH
NEW: PDF for pamphlet version
Major Declaration from the Revcoms:
WE NEED AND WE DEMAND:
A WHOLE NEW WAY TO LIVE,
A FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT SYSTEM
In the name of the people… In the name of humanity…
We Declare and Demand:
The Existing Capitalist-Imperialist System And Institutions Of Government In This Country Must Be Abolished And Dismantled—And Replaced By A New, Socialist System Based On The CONSTITUTION FOR THE NEW SOCIALIST REPUBLIC IN NORTH AMERICA
• Read the full declaration
• Order bundles and distribute everywhere
WE ARE THE REVCOMS (REVOLUTIONARY COMMUNISTS): WE ARE WORKING FOR A REAL REVOLUTION AND A WHOLE NEW, EMANCIPATING WAY TO LIVE
• Read the text of proclamation issued May 1, 2023
• Get PDFs of the broadsheet for -print-ing: Cover/Back/Centerfold
Climate Devastation... Nuclear War Threatened... The -dir-ect Danger of All-Out Fascism... Times Like These Demand a Revolutionary Answer
THE BOB AVAKIAN INTERVIEWS
on The RNL—Revolution, Nothing Less!—Show
• Videos: Interview Part 1/Part 2/Part 3
• A Message to the Revcoms and Everyone Else Yearning for a Better World: THIS Is A “Game-Changer”: The Bob Avakian Interviews (Part 1/Part 2/Part 3/Part 4)
2024 SCENARIOS (A SKETCH), AND THE CHALLENGES, by Bob Avakian, Revolutionary Leader, Author of the New Communism
Two Systems. Two Constitutions. Two Futures.
• U.S. Constitution: An Exploiters’ Vision of Freedom—Added Notes (and Brief Introduction), by Bob Avakian (Download PDF pamphlet)
• Constitution for the New Socialist Republic in North America
• Video from The RNL Show: Bob Avakian on Why He Wrote the Constitution for the New Socialist Republic in North America
SOMETHING TERRIBLE,´-or-SOMETHING TRULY EMANCIPATING:
Profound Crisis, Deepening Divisions, The Looming Possibility Of Civil War—
And The Revolution That Is Urgently Needed
A Necessary Foundation, A Basic Roadmap For This Revolution
by Bob Avakian, Revolutionary Leader, Author of the New Communism
• Audio: Listen to Bob Avakian Reading "Something Terrible,´-or-Something Truly Emancipating"
• REVOLUTION IS POSSIBLE, THIS RARE TIME MUST BE SEIZED—important excerpts from "Something Terrible,´-or-Something Truly Emancipating"
REVOLUTION: MAJOR TURNING POINTS AND RARE OPPORTUNITIES
Or... Why did Lenin talk about World War 1 as a “stage manager” of revolution?...
And why did Mao say, We should thank Japan for invading China? by Bob Avakian
REVOLUTION: A REAL CHANCE TO WIN, by Bob Avakian
Part One: We Are Serious
Part Two: A Scientifically Based Strategy
Part Three: Civil War and Revolution
Part Four: Hard Core Youth and the Revolution
Part Five: Winning and Winning
PDF of pamphlet with all five parts
Organizing for an Actual Revolution: 7 Key Points
ALLEGIANCE
• Read and spread
• A Special RNL Show Dispatch
• Download poster PDF/JPG
• Download flyer PDF
BOB AVAKIAN: A RADICALLY DIFFERENT LEADER—A WHOLE NEW FRAMEWORK FOR HUMAN EMANCIPATION
Bob Avakian (BA) is the most important political thinker and leader in the world today.
State of Emergency
• STATE OF EMERGENCY: CHAINS ON PEOPLE WHO DESPERATELY NEED TO BE FREE: A message from Bob Avakian, revolutionary leader, author and architect of a whole new framework for human emancipation: the new communism
Audio of this piece by Bob Avakian
• Illustrated version of BA s article from The RNL Show: State of Emergency...
Posters: What is that? Who said that? Say what? Provoke. Inspire. Drive people to the BA Interviews on The RNL Show
A point in response to the (all too common) carping—especially from among people in "the educated middle class"—about our "promotion of one leader"
"Cult"—An Ignorant and Cowardly Slander
Bob Avakian Speaks to "Cult": A Ridiculous, Ignorant and Irresponsible Accusation
These two articles by Bob Avakian on exploitation—and putting an end to exploitation and oppression— contain a very concentrated and popularized understanding of basic essentials as to what this capitalist-imperialist system actually is, and what it actually rests on, why it has to be overthrown and replaced by a socialist system aiming for a communist world, and what are essential elements of that new society and world.
• PUTTING AN END TO EXPLOITATION, AND ALL OPPRESSION
• EXPLOITATION: WHAT IT IS, HOW TO PUT AN END TO IT
Killer Mike, Ice Cube, WHY CAPITALIST PROGRAMS and BOURGEOIS ASPIRATIONS CANNOT LEAD TO LIBERATION and WHY WE NEED A REAL REVOLUTION
THE TRIALS OF FASCIST DONALD TRUMP, AND THE CRIMINAL NATURE OF THIS WHOLE SYSTEM
Or, Don’t Be Played for Suckers by Trump’s Posturing,´-or-the Democrats’ Posing as Defenders of Justice—We Need a Revolution and a Fundamentally Different and Far Better System, by Bob Avakian
CAPITALISTS, ANTI-COMMUNISTS: BLATANT HYPOCRISY, GLARING CONTRADICTION, by Bob Avakian
Listen to the audio of this piece by Bob Avakian
GOD, PREJUDICE, OPPRESSION, TERROR AND THE WAY OUT OF THIS MADNESS, by Bob Avakian (download PDF)
Stop the U.S.-Backed Israeli Genocidal War Against Palestine!
The Palestinian People Must Be Free!
Down With the Racist Apartheid State of Israel and Its Master, U.S. Imperialism!
Stop the Repression, Censorship and Blacklisting of Pro-Palestinian Voices!
From the Imperialist USA to Palestine The People Need Real Revolution Based on the New Communism!
• Resource page on the genocidal assault on Palestine—and Israel as an Enforcer of Imperialism [updated]
• Some Basic Truths About the U.S.-Supported Israeli War Against Palestine, by Bob Avakian
• A Timely Provocation from Bob Avakian
• The Moral Blind Spot of Supporters of Israel Who Criticize Hamas—and Hamas Alone—for Murdering Children, by Bob Avakian
• Yes, There Can Be No “Equivalence” Between Israel and the Palestinians—But the Reality Is the Reverse of What Supporters of Israel Insist, by Bob Avakian
• Video: Bob Avakian on the Two Meanings of "Never Again"
• For the Revcoms, Including People in and Around the Revolution Clubs: PALESTINE, ISRAEL, IMPERIALISM: WAR, THE DANGER OF EVEN GREATER WAR—AND REVOLUTION
BASIC ORIENTATION, COMPELLING AGITATION AND MOVING MASSES, by Bob Avakian
• Essential Writings from Bob Avakian on the Middle East, Israel and the Revolution—and the World—We Need
• A message from the Revcoms: TO ALL THOSE WHO HAVE STOOD UP FOR THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE AGAINST THE US-BACKED ISRAELI GENOCIDAL WAR
Featured
• An Open Letter from Sunsara Taylor and a Team of Revcoms, January 2024
Students, Faculty, Administrators, and Everyone with a Conscience:
THE WORLD IS BEING RADICALLY CHANGED
WHAT YOU DO—OR FAIL TO DO—CAN MAKE ALL THE DIFFERENCE
Available now: PDF of open letter for -print-ing flyers
Fund-raising
• DONATE NOW to Revcom.us immediate funding needs
What Would You Give for 2024 to be Our Year—A Year of Revolution?
-$-10,000 Needed for Website Revcom.us by March 1
The RNL—Revolution, Nothing Less!—Show
• VIDEO: Bob Avakian for the Liberation of Black People and the Emancipation of All Humanity
• The RNL—Revolution, Nothing Less!—Show Podcast!!
Repression, Resistance and the Potential for Revolution in Iran
• From the International Emergency Campaign to Free Iran’s Political Prisoners Now (IEC): Razor-Sharp Two-Sided Battle: Clashes Persist Over Compulsory Hijab in Iran
• From the International Emergency Campaign to Free Iran s Political Prisoners Now (IEC): Political Prisoner Nahid Taghavi Released on Furlough
• From Atash/Fire, journal of the Communist Party of Iran, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist: On the Importance of Truth to Achieving Emancipation: A Letter to Narges Mohammadi from Somayeh Kargar
• From Atash/Fire #146, Journal of the Communist Party of Iran, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist: The Reality of Communism: What Is Social Democracy and Why Is It a Capitalist Dictatorship? Part 4
• From Atash/Fire #145, Journal of the Communist Party of Iran, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist: The Reality of Communism, Democracy and Freedom of Expression—The Economic Base Is the Decisive Factor! Part 3
• From Atash/Fire #144, Journal of the Communist Party of Iran, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist: The Reality of Communism, The Reality of Democracy and the Ideal of Democracy, Part 2
• From Atash/Fire #143, Journal of the Communist Party of Iran, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist: The Reality of Communism, Bourgeois Democracy Means Class Dictatorship of the Bourgeoisie, Part 1
Bootlickers Gallery
• Minstrels for Trump
• Nominations Now Open for Bootlickers Hall of Shame
The Communist Revolution so Badly Needed… vs. the Anti-Communist Brainwash You’re Getting: Raymond Lotta Fall Speaking Tour
• Video: The Truth About the Ukraine War: Refuting Timothy Snyder’s Lies, Demagoguery & War Mongering, Raymond Lotta, from The RNL Show
• Trafficking in Lies, Demagoguery, and War Mongering: Timothy Snyder is a Vicious Anti-Communist Ideologue... And Shameless Apologist for the U.S. Empire: A Challenge to Debate from Raymond Lotta (Summary/Challenge)
• Video: Raymond Lotta Kicks Off the Fall Speaking Tour on “The Communist Revolution So Badly Needed… vs. the Anti-Communist Brainwash You’re Getting,” Revolution Books NYC, September 19
• Learn About the Tour… Bring Raymond Lotta to Your Campus
• Against the Anti-Communist Brainwash... Socialist China’s Great Leap Forward of 1958-60:
What It Was Actually About, Why It Is Attacked, and the Actual Causes of Famine, by Raymond Lotta
• Resource page: The True History of Communist Revolution
• More on the Socialist Experience
“Woke” Is a Destructive Force
• Rich and Lively Engagement About “‘Woke’ Lunacy vs. Real Revolution” at Two Universities in North Carolina
• “Woke” Lunacy vs. Real Revolution National Tour Hits Houston
• A Seven Point Indictment: “Woke” is a destructive force in the political, intellectual, artistic and ethical life of society
• Video: “Woke” Lunacy vs. Real Revolution, a speech by Sunsara Taylor (a special episode of The RNL—Revolution, Nothing Less!—Show)
• Special page: Get involved with the Sunsara Taylor Campus Speaking Tour
• Bob Avakian on Opposing “Woke” Madness and Obstructions
The Revolution Club
• Taking the Struggle Against the U.S.-Backed Israeli Genocide of Palestinians and Real Revolution to the Trains of LA
• "No fascist Trump, no Genocide Joe, the whole damn system s got to go!" and other chants from the Revolution Club, LA
• Message from the Revcoms: To Those Saying, "Why Should I Care About the People in Gaza"
• Joe Veale on The RNL—Revolution Nothing Less!—Show on the Points of Attention, the Code of the Revolution
• Live by and Fight for These Six Points of Attention, the Code of the Revolution!
• Go here to find out about the Revolution Club
SCIENTIFIC COMMUNIST THEORY AND THE PROBLEM WITH “MASS LINE,” by Bob Avakian
ANTI-SCIENTIFIC “ANTI-AUTHORITARIANISM”: Serving American Imperialism and Promoting American Chauvinism, by Bob Avakian (Download PDF pamphlet)
Reality and Distortions of Reality—Objective Truth and Subjective Influences, by Ardea Skybreak
No Nuclear War! It’s This System, Not Humanity, That Needs to Become Extinct!
• A World in Flames: Imperialist Bloodbath in Ukraine Expands, War Preparations in East Asia Intensify
• War in Ukraine: Frequently Asked Questions
• Piercing the Lies, Digging Beneath the Surface
The Larger Dynamics of the World Imperialist System Driving the War in Ukraine... And a Lesson from When There Was a Genuinely Socialist Soviet -union-, by Raymond Lotta
• Resource Page on the War in Ukraine and U.S. Threats Against China
Bob Avakian on Imperialist Gangsters and the Need for Revolution — Essential Reading
• “DON’T WORRY ABOUT A NUCLEAR WAR—IF THERE IS ONE, RUSSIA WILL LOSE!”
The Dangerous Demagoguery of Timothy Snyder
On Behalf of U.S. Imperialism and Its Proxy War in Ukraine
• THE WAR IN UKRAINE AND THE INTERESTS OF HUMANITY: A SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTIONARY APPROACH VS. HARMFUL CONFUSION AND CHAUVINIST DELUSION
Bob Avakian Responds to People Who Should Know Better (and Maybe Once Did)
• Shameless American Chauvinism: "Anti-Authoritarianism" as a "Cover" for Supporting U.S. Imperialism, with added note by Bob Avakian
From Bob Avakian
• LIBERALS… LIAR, LIAR: In honor of Daniel Ellsberg: who was willing and determined to face, to speak—and to urge others to speak out about—crucial truths about the crimes of this American empire and the dangers it poses to the people of the world and the very existence of humanity
[including video]
• About Bill Maher— A Further Observation on American Chauvinism And Parasitic Individualism
WHAT SYSTEM IS RESPONSIBLE FOR WHAT HAPPENED TO TYRE NICHOLS AND THOUSANDS MORE? THE POLICING SYSTEM´-or-THE SYSTEM THE POLICING SERVES?, by Bob Avakian
RACIAL OPPRESSION CAN BE ENDED—BUT NOT UNDER THIS SYSTEM, by Bob Avakian
ABOLITION—REAL AND ILLUSORY, by Bob Avakian
Bob Avakian on The Oppression of Black People and the Revolutionary Struggle to End All Oppression, with American Crimes: The Ugly History of This Country — a Resource Page
Bob Avakian on the Struggle for Abortion Rights, the Oppression of Women, and the Revolutionary Struggle to Emancipate ALL Humanity
• Video: Bob Avakian on Why You Can’t Break All the Chains Except One...
• Video: From The Bob Avakian Interviews: What Accounts For The Attack On Abortion And What Must Be Done
• THE CRUCIAL FIGHT FOR ABORTION RIGHTS AND ENDING ALL OPPRESSION
Broad Unity and Necessary Struggle
Featured from Bob Avakian
• Essential readings from BA
• Palestine
• Ukraine
• "Woke" Obstructions
• Abortion
• The Oppression of Black People
• BA: A Different Kind of Leader
• Internationalism
• What Is Science?
• Revolution Not Reform
• BA on Fascism
Revolutionary Hope/La esperanza revolucionaria, Revolutionary Communist Organization, Mexico